I Do Like The ‘Peace Be With You’ Part…We Should All Do That Everyday On The Street

By John

Last night I went to mass for the first time in years. It was the Feast of the Ascension, and I went with my friend and her mother, where we met up with another friend and her family.

I don’t talk much about religion here, mainly because I feel it’s something that is not only private, but a delicate subject for some people. On the other hand, religion is one of the things that is at the focal point of many of the controversies within the past…oh…forever. Without dialogue, nothing will develop. Also, I talk about what I want, when I want. So here it goes.

Back in high school, I was an avid church goer. Raised Catholic, I was confirmed when I was 15 and became a Peer Leader within a church organization. From then on, I helped run retreats for freshmen and sophomores who were going through their confirmation. Hell, I even worked as an assistant for the parish. Every Sunday I could be seen in the pews, reciting song and prayer along with everyone else. I was also trained as a Eucharistic Minister.

Once I got to college and came out*, things began to change. Not that I wasn’t aware of who or what I was prior to my college experiences, but there was a definite change in my viewpoints. Coming out forced me to take a much more focused look at some of the things that had been a part of me for so long.

*When looking back on things, I always knew I was gay. I just never identified as a gay person. I just happened to be attracted to men. I didn’t realize until much later in my life that this was ‘gay’. Soon thereafter, I had come out to a friend, back during my junior year of high school. However, I consider my official coming out to be when I decided to not be closeted in college.

One of these things was my religion. Now, I’m speaking from a personal experience here, and am by no means speaking for anyone else but myself. Once I began to get a grasp on how my church viewed me as a person, I started to distance myself. It’s painful to be faced with an entire institution who believes you to be a sinner, an abomination, diseased or all of the above and still sit in those same pews as before. If there’s one thing I try to uphold in my life, it’s honesty. Honesty is the thing that I hold as the most pristine of virtues. And to sit in a place that thinks so lowly of me while I still tried to be an active congregate was dishonest to myself.

So over the years, I gradually stopped going to church. It was too hard to sit in those pews that I once sang in and try to ignore the hatred that cemented that building’s wall. I found it hypocritical of them and weak of me.

For me, the church was a few things. It was a place where I could go to think and be at peace. It was a place where I had formed strong, lasting friendships. It was a place where, every Sunday, without fail, I could be sure to see the faces of friends. It was the place where I formed my relationship with God.

Now, I feel differently. As welcoming as the faces are, and as much love as I feel from them while sharing this time with them, the institution itself doesn’t want me there. That’s something I don’t feel I will ever be able to reconcile with. Yet I’m still torn. Catholicism, and more specifically my church, has given me so much in terms of friendships and experiences, it’s hard to completely ignore.

Am I religious? Spiritual? Celestially obsessed? It depends. I believe in a God. I believe that this God is loving, forgiving and understanding. And I believe this God is accepting of everyone. Do I believe all of the things I’ve learned, read and been told concerning God? Not at all. I don’t think the Bible is the word of God. How can it be? There are words in English that can’t even be translated into French, yet I’m to believe the Bible is as perfect as the day God had someone scribble it down? I don’t think anyone can live by the standards of another man. They can only live to the best of their abilities and hope for the best in the end.

When I’m asked about my religion, I get a little divided. Do I say Catholic? I’m certainly not fluent in any other religion, yet I’m not atheist or agnostic. So I’ve created my own religion, which I feel I’m entirely permitted to do. I’m the only member of Johntholicism, as far as I know, and it’s a religion that suits me surprisingly well.

10 Responses to “I Do Like The ‘Peace Be With You’ Part…We Should All Do That Everyday On The Street”

  1. Simon Says:

    Doesn’t Christianity say all people are sinners? We are born sinful, in which case, being gay shouldn’t put you in a different boat to any of the others.
    I thought that was the whole point.

  2. V-Grrrl Says:

    If you haven’t already, you should read some of Andrew Sullivan’s essays. He’s gay, he’s Catholic, he criticizes and analyzes the church, and yet he remains part of it. He writes for Time and has his own Web site, where he addresses loads of political topics. Also has had numerous books published on gay rights. Smart, insightful, interesting.

    I was raised Catholic but became an Episcopalian in my early 20s. Lots of reasons for that, but among the big ones was that the Episcopal church upholds the integrity of liturgy and tradition while remaining willing to examine its practices and change as its leaders AND members feel led.

    So our clergy can be married, we have women priests and bishops, and a few years ago, an openly gay priest (with a live-in partner) was ordained as a bishop. Right? Wrong? We’re still figuring that out and trying to be respectful as different members of the church assert their thinking on the matter. That’s what I love about my church–there’s an ongoing DIALOGUE about what it means to a Christian.

    Didn’t mean to preach! Just sharing. You’ll find your place–and no one can or should tell you where it is.

  3. John Says:

    Simon,

    The reason why I’m not okay with my label as sinner is because of the idea that if you are gay, you are a sinner for that. Being gay isn’t anything I have any control over, so to be labeled a sinner for that is unfair. I also find the whole ‘love the sinner, hate the sin’ idea to be degrading as well.

    V-Grrrl,

    Preach away. It’s the comments section! I’ve never heard of this man, Andrew Sullivan, before. I’ll have to look into his readings. Especially to find out his reasons for staying in the church. That I would find to be interesting.

  4. Flubberwinkle Says:

    I never could understand why homosexuality is frowned upon in Catholic and Orthodox Church(es). (I’m not aware of the other religions). If all the preaching is about love, why is this love considered tainted?

    V-grrrl’s explanation of the Episcopal church …”willing to examine its practices and change”… sends an encouraging note that perhaps not all churches are rigid and overbearing.

    Johntholicism! Praise the blog author for his humour and open-mindedness. Hallelujah!

  5. Irish Eyes Says:

    Lovah,
    I’ve been meaning to tell you this, and this is as good a place as any.

    Thank you.

    Thank you for being a thoughtful gay man who stands up for himself and his beliefs in the most non-confrontational way I have every experienced. I can honestly say you have been the biggest influence in me and my activism within the LGBT community.

    Also, I saw Bill Nye the Science Guy yesterday. Maybe I could ask him to be to Johntholicism what Tom Cruise is to Scientology.

    Also, come visit.

  6. #1 Dancer Says:

    Hmm… I am a ‘bad’ Catholic here in that I don’t know what the ‘official teaching’ is of the church – but I think that’s mostly because I don’t want to know what it is. I came back to the church in a very progressive (yet somehow traditional) setting [Go St. Mary's!!] and the pervading atmosphere there was the proverbial ‘don’t throw stones’ concept. Accept all and love all. That’s the church I want to believe in and the one I personally belong to so count me in as a parishioner of Johntholicism. Sounds good to me!

  7. aka Brandi Says:

    I have stuff to say, but it’s swirling around in there and hurting my head. Tater & I, too, are lapsed Catholics. I can sometimes smell the hypocrisy, surrounding me in the pews, but unlike my sister, am not quite ready to turn away. I love the Tradition of our Faith. I don’t go to church now, but am comforted by the fact that I can still say, “I am Catholic” and return at any time I choose.

    In college I had a really cool priest who allowed that we could still Be Catholic, even while not agreeing with all of the Church’s tenets. I have a feeling Johntholicism is dangerously close to Paigetholicism.

    (Someday I’ll go back, but for now I need a break. We didn’t have the best experience at the base chapel in Japan and I’m afraid they may have lost Dillon and Mac.)

    See how swirly that was?

  8. Irish Eyes Says:

    John Kerry goes to my church. He’ll probably be down for it if Bill is busy building rockets. Also, I miss you visit me make Paige feed us and fill us with liquor!

  9. aka Brandi Says:

    Do come here! I will feed you! And water you! (But I will not feed you lasagne. Someone doesn’t like it.)

    PS – the “peace be with you” part is my least favorite part. I requires me to talk to and touch strangers. I have a few issues.

  10. Annie, The Evil Queen Says:

    These are some of the many reason we moved away from the Catholic Church. We’re on Team Presbyterian now. We’re feeling it out. My sister is gay and I hate that anyone could think she’s going to hell just because of who she loves. It boggles my mind.

    I like the “peace be with you” part too. Does Johntolicism do wine? If there’s wine, sign us up.

Leave a Reply